• AquariumPlants' CO2 Electronic Regulator & Solenoid



    When I first received my CO2 regulator from AquariumPlants.com, I thought I'd run it for about a month on my tank before doing a review. By the next day, I felt I was ready to sit down and start typing it up. The fact is, if you need a new regulator for your CO2 tank, this is the one - there's nothing to debate. (For the record, I've been using it for a month - life got in the way and the review had to wait.)

    I've been wanting to buy one of these for years, but whenever I needed it, I was low on cash and opted for something less expensive. Over the past six years of running a calcium reactor, I've used six regulators - some purchased, some borrowed, and this one. Frankly, I was excited when I finally committed and placed my order, and for $189 I finally got mine! Shipping was free because the product was over their $175 threshold.

    A CO2 regulator controls the flow of CO2 gas coming out of a storage cylinder. For saltwater application, we use it with a calcium reactor to lower the pH of the water within the reactor and dissolve the media to produce alkalinity and liquid calcium around the clock for a reef tank. Usually they come with two gauges; one to measure the quantity remaining in the cylinder and one to measure the pressure of the gas exiting via a needle valve. Most hobbyists choose to purchase a regulator with a solenoid that will shut off the flow of gas whenever a power outage occurs. Some, but not all, regulators come with a bubble counter.

    The Aquarium Plants' Electronic CO2 Regulator does all of this, and more. Instead of seeing the flow of bubbles rising a in small vial of fluid, a red LED flashes on and off representing each bubble. When the power goes out, the unit shuts off and the LED ceases to blink. The biggest selling point to me, other than their boast that it is "the most precise CO2 regulator in the world," is that it comes with a three year warranty. Had I purchased one six years ago, I'd be on my second one now. The fact that is has such a long warranty period tells me that it is a quality product and that the company is willing to stand behind it for more than 1000 days. Over 26,000 hours of continuous reliable CO2 control.

    The instructions are on a single page, and are easy to understand. It connects to the CO2 tank with a wrench (not included), and the stand-off pipe is longer than usual to accommodate the black box. A single power cord supplies power to that box. A nipple located at the lower left is for the 1/4" flexible tubing that runs to the calcium reactor. The large black knob controls how much pressure is flowing to the tubing (in the picture above, it reads 7.5 PSI). The smaller knob on the black box allows the user to set how often a bubble will pass.

    For our application, setting it to 1 would be 1bps (bubble per second). Turning it counter-clockwise will increase the bubble rate to as much as 10bps. I was running mine at 3bps originally (and have been for years) but have since backed off to 1bps because it has sufficed my reef's needs. Good husbandry requires that we continue to test water parameters, including alkalinity and calcium levels. Minor adjustments are necessary from time to time to keep those numbers stable.

    Coupling this device with a pH controller makes it plug & play, but that will have to be a different review. Back to this product, I should mention that the company included a small clear check valve to prevent water flowing back into the regulator. I would have liked some type of tiny hose clamp to hold the tubing to the nipple, but since there was none I improvised with a small ziptie instead.

    Below is a brief video of it in action. As you watch the light flash, you'll notice the PSI gauge's needle bounces like a heart beat. I've not seen this with any other regulator.

    Comments 15 Comments
    1. Turbosek's Avatar
      Turbosek -
      Thanks for the write up. I just bought my first calcium reactor, and I opted for this exact same regulator. It seemed worth spending the extra $50-$60 for this regulator versus a standard one. This regulator is a no-brainer when it comes to comparing with others on the market. I have yet to use it...I have the reactor running with just water, but I plan to start CO2 once I get my calcium and alk levels correct. I have a question....I have the Lifereef Calc Reactor....like yours. It has a bubble counter attached. Do I still keep this hooked up, or could I ditch it?
    1. johnbanks's Avatar
      johnbanks -
      I like reviews like this one. Nice and simple, eloquent and to the point without bitching. I don't have a calc reactor as my tanks small enough to get by with just additives and water changes. Look forward to more reviews like this one.

      John
    1. melev's Avatar
      melev -
      Turbosek - You can leave it on the reactor. I removed mine because it crazed like it was WWIII. I thought it was about to shatter, so I reconnected the pieces without that section.

      Thanks John. We have another review that is pending, and I hope it meets your approval.
    1. washingtond's Avatar
      washingtond -
      Great review and may look into getting one at some point. Our current regulator has been working without any issues for 4 years now but when it comes time to replace, this will be the one.
    1. marinelife's Avatar
      marinelife -
      Thanks for posting this. Looks like I found my next bubble counter
    1. HeneryH's Avatar
      HeneryH -
      As you watch the light flash, you'll notice the PSI gauge's needle bounces like a heart beat. I've not seen this with any other regulator.
      I suppose it is acting in an electronic binary full-on full-off mode for each bubble??

      The old-school used a needle valve to physically leak out the Co2 at a steady rate.
    1. melev's Avatar
      melev -
      I don't know. I don't plan to take the black box apart to see what makes it tick.
    1. marinelife's Avatar
      marinelife -
      Would you recommend a better check valve than the one they send?
    1. melev's Avatar
      melev -
      Not necessarily. I simply had two inline already on my reactor so I didn't use theirs as well.
    1. Saltnewbie's Avatar
      Saltnewbie -
      the bouncing needle is normal. Mine does the same thing. it because instead of a needle valve slowing the flow rate the box actually counts the bubble and opens and closes more or less a solenoid. Thats why you get the pulsing effect
    1. marinelife's Avatar
      marinelife -
      Did you have any trouble with the bleed test. Mine drops from 450psi to 400 and stays around there.
    1. melev's Avatar
      melev -
      No, I've not noticed anything like that.
    1. marinelife's Avatar
      marinelife -
      I can not get this to stop failing the bleed test. I have talked to them a few times. Driving me nuts!
    1. melev's Avatar
      melev -
      Have you tried using soapy water to verify you aren't losing any gas at the brass connection?
    1. KathyL's Avatar
      KathyL -
      I think this might work better than other regulators for giving CO2 to phytoplankton cultures…. bubble counters are so iffy, and in my experience check valves don't work once the solenoid shuts off and there is back pressure. THANKS!